MEDIA
RELEASE
17 November 2007
Embargo:
none
125 MPs BRANDED 'HYPOCRITES'
OVER EU REBATE VOTE
More
than 125 MPs have been branded 'hypocrites' over a looming vote
in Parliament on Britain's EU rebate, including several cabinet
ministers and many MPs in Labour's most marginal seats.
As
part of the deal done in December 2005, Tony Blair agreed to surrender
£7bn of Britain's refund from the EU budget, increasing our annual
contribution to the EU budget to £10.5bn.
On
Monday, MPs will vote to approve that deal when the European Communities
(Finance) Bill receives its second reading in Parliament.
The
vote comes as the EU Court of Auditors last week refused to approve
the "majority" of the EU's spending for the 13th year running.
The
government is also under increasing fire for a range of public service
failures, such as high rates of superbug infections in hospitals,
post office closures, local council service cuts and ill-equipped
armed forces.
A
survey of MPs' voting intentions has revealed that at least 129
of the 360 MPs who intend to approve the unjustifiably large increase
in funds paid to the audit-failing EU are facing cuts to local services
in their own constituencies.
For
example, Home Secretary Jacqui Smith's Redditch constituency
is set to be hit by cuts to local public services or big increases
in council tax, as the county council tries to shave £25 million
off its budget in the wake of a poor funding settlement from the
government.
In
Bolton, where Transport secretary Ruth Kelly has her constituency,
the town council is looking to cut £5.2m (a mere few hours worth
of the extra money the EU will enjoy) from its budget to limit council
tax rises, likely causing job losses and service cuts. This is the
second round of cuts to the council's budget to be considered this
year.
Environment
secretary Hilary Benn's constituency of Leeds Central remains
under serious repeat threat of flooding as the Environment Agency
has blocked a plan for new flood defences citing "financial pressures".
Communities
secretary Hazel Blears has already been branded a 'hypocrite'
in her Salford constituency after joining protests against changes
to hospital and maternity services and then welcoming the cuts.
The
same cuts, experienced across Manchester, also affected the Stretford
& Urmston constituency of Schools minister Beverley Hughes.
Similarly
Health minister Ivan Lewis has seen cuts to maternity services
in his own constituency of Bury South.
MPs
in some of Labour's most marginal seats are also risking a public
backlash that could lose them their seats, by intending to approve
the multi-billion pound raise for the audit-failing EU while local
services face cuts. For
example;
-
Clive Efford MP for Eltham has criticised the axing of emergency
facilities at local hospitals, but intends to send money to the
EU that could instead have been used to keep those local services
operating;
-
Martin Linton MP for Battersea faces local NHS cuts and reduced
police numbers;
-
Swindon North and South MPs Anne Snelgrove and Michael Wills
plan to gift billions more to the EU while their local hospital
makes £600,000 cuts to its cleaning budget;
-
Joan Ryan MP for Enfield North seems to think the extra payments
to the EU can be afforded while her local hospital is failing to
meet targets for tackling superbug infections.
-
Watford MP Claire Ward postures in support of attempts to
secure a new hospital in the town and a local NHS Trust that is
described as financially "weak", while quietly planning to vote
away billions of pounds to the EU that could solve these local difficulties
affecting her constituents;
-
Basildon MP Angela Smith (PPS to Gordon Brown) is another
whose local council is facing a cash crisis and considering service
cuts.
Seven
Liberal Democrat and two Conservative MPs have also come under fire
for hypocrisy.
Ian
Taylor MP for Esher & Walton has protested about the downgrading
of nearby Epsom hospital, but quietly intends to approve the unjustified
government handout of billions more pounds to the EU that could
instead be used to prevent such cuts.
And
John Gummer MP's Suffolk Coastal constituency is threatened
by county-wide multi-million-pound cuts to road maintenance, bus
services, elderly care services and extra-curricular activities
in schools as Suffolk County Council tries to plug a funding black
hole.
All
these local cuts are being caused by funding shortfalls that are
tiny fractions of the billions these MPs are planning to approve
gifting to the EU.
The
research, conducted by the Democracy Movement - a leading eurosceptic
pressure group - lists 360 MPs in total who have either said they
will approve the deal or who have avoided several chances - including
enquiries from constituents, direct communication and votes in Parliament
- to signal that they oppose the Bill.
The
results have been arranged into a Hall of Hypocrisy,
ranking the MPs by their majority and level of threats to local
public services.
Top
of the ranking is Laura Moffat, MP for Crawley, who holds
her seat by a tiny margin of 37 votes, has faced a succession of
problems with local health services, yet still intends to vote to
approve handing billions of pounds extra to the audit-failing EU.
The
ranking shows how vulnerable many MPs are to being seen wasting
huge amounts of public money while local services are left wanting.
DM
director Stuart Coster said:
"No
benefit whatsoever can be claimed for increasing payments to the
EU while auditors cannot explain how the "majority" of the EU's
current budget is being spent.
"MPs
can hardly claim to be 'standing up' for local public services while
planning to approve the waste of billions of pounds extra on the
EU, which remains unable to obtain auditors approval for the majority
of its spending.
"Some
MPs seem to be living in a fantasy land where splashing extra billions
on funding the EU without justification will not impact on the level
of funds remaining for essential public services.
"MPs
who vote billions of pounds away to be spent unaccountably must
realise that they will be expected to take personal responsibility
for the ultimately very local consequences.
"Come
the next election, MPs who vote to approve this Bill will be listed
in our Hall of Hypocrisy and held personally responsible for public
service shortfalls, particularly those in their own constituencies,
that could have been avoided if they had not voted to waste more
billions on the EU."
[Ends]
CONTACTS:
Stuart Coster, DM Head Office - 020 7603 7796
NOTES:
1.
To view the DM's Hall of Hypocrisy and accompanying links
to reports of cuts in specific constituencies, click here
2.
European Communities (Finance) Bill 2007-08: click here
3.
EU Council Decision of 7th June 2007 on the new EU Own Resources Decision,
to which the Bill refers: click here
4.
EC (Finance) Bill parliamentary schedule: click here
5.
£43.4 billion of European taxpayers' spending open to fraud - Open Europe
briefing: click here
6.
The Democracy Movement
is the eurosceptic pressure group that formed out of the Referendum
Party - since conducting major grass-roots campaigns and distributing
millions of pieces of literature on keeping the pound and against the
EU Constitution.
Today
the movement is Britain's largest eurosceptic pressure group by a considerable
margin, with more than 300,000 registered supporters and over 100 local
branches nation-wide.
|